review-ledger.md

Review ledger

Newest section at the top. One section per review run. This is the record of what a run measured, what it changed, what it deliberately did not change, and what the next run should not spend time re-deciding.

2026-10-04 (needs-review sweep #54-#57, 2D fields #41, client tests #67)

Every entry listed in #54-#57 (37) was re-read at its source on 2026-10-04. Each one has verified: 2026-10-04 and a dated Evidence line quoting what was read.

• Now active (9):
  • budgetpixel-sfx: CC BY 4.0, games named. Still tagged ai-generated.
  • accurig.
  • gaea: EULA.txt from the official archive. Community Edition is non-commercial, so commercial: false.
  • pnggauntlet and xnormal: the licence is read from the files inside the official installer, since the web has none. Notes say so.
  • charge-materials: CC BY 4.0, from the asset detail panel.
  • penzilla: corrected to commercial: false. The Standard License needs a paid invoice for any use and credit is mandatory.
  • fontshare: the ITF FFL allows games. Notes warn that its ban on file conversion may cover SDF/atlas baking.
  • charmorph: commercial: varies, because the mb_* bases make the exported model AGPL.
• Corrected but still needs-review:
  • echothief: the SDSURF licence PDF bars "gaming" without a separate commercial licence, so license: custom, commercial: false.
  • ccmixter, free-music-archive and sketchfab: commercial: varies.
  • prelinger-archives: credit is not required. Only 1,871 of 10,468 items carry the public-domain dedication.
• Still needs-review (open questions are in each entry's Notes): convology-xt, freesound, musopen, pacdv, soundbible, cheetah-texture-packer, ezspritesheet, fracplanet, multipaint, pngyu, wwise, dcss-tiles, godot-shaders, lospec, material-maker-gallery, opengameart, poly-pizza, scan-the-world, textureking, destockd, mixkit-stock-video, nasa-image-video-library, truebones-zoo. These are mostly per-file aggregators, or questions only the publisher can answer.
• #41: added camera_perspective to 8 2D entries and grid_dimensions: 16x16 to kenney-roguelike-characters. Each value comes from the source page or its preview. Entries left without a value are mixed-style aggregators, palettes, or packs of varying size. kenney-pixel-vehicle-pack's summary is corrected to side-on.
• #67: the catalog search, URL state, filters and 404 guesses moved to site/lib/search.mjs, which the build copies to dist/search.js. app.js and not-found.js now load as modules and import it. The sync-counts and new-entry text rewrites moved to site/lib/scaffold.mjs. All are covered in lib.test.mjs (401 assertions).

2026-10-04 (repo review, #59-#75)

A whole-repo review (code, docs, live site) filed #59-#75. This run fixed the code and doc items. No entry's licence data changed.

• Exports: feed.xml gets a feed-level <author> (#59). catalog.csv puts an apostrophe before cells starting = + - @, tab or CR (#62).
• Build robustness: LINK_RE is now shared by markdown.mjs and llms.mjs, so balanced-paren hrefs read the same in both (#60). renderInline strips NUL before using it as the slot marker. The validator rejects C0 control characters (#61).
• One entry walker: site/lib/entry-files.mjs is used by build, validate, sync-counts and check-links; hidden and _scratch folders are skipped everywhere. The validator enforces kebab-case ids (#64).
• Link check: the pure parts moved to site/lib/link-check.mjs, with tests. Multi-part suffixes (co.uk, github.io, ...) are handled, and report URLs are inert code spans. V16 rejects localhost, .local and IP-literal URLs (#65).
• Client: lookup maps have no prototype. The shortlist export normalises the trailing slash (#66). The shortlist button's accessible name starts with its visible text (#63).
• Docs: "not legal advice" in the README, licences guide, every page footer and the CREDITS export (#68). README positioning against magictools and awesome-gamedev, with credit (#71). ROADMAP made count-free (#69). Contributor steps aligned; TEMPLATE starts needs-review (#70). Specs moved to docs/design/. research-index taken out of the user guides, and trust-score relabelled as a rubric (#73).
• SEO: homepage WebSite + Dataset JSON-LD (#74).
• Not changed, deliberately: homepage weight (#75) needs a decision about pre-rendering every row versus slimming data.js. The Code of Conduct contact (#72) needs a private address from the maintainer. Client-side JS still has no tests (#67, partly done).

2026-09-30 (magictools import)

Candidates were taken from the awesome list ellisonleao/magictools: every non-paid item in every section. Its emoji licence legend was not trusted. Each source was re-read at its own licence page, repo or bundled licence file on 2026-09-30. The catalog went from 334 to 376 entries.

• Added, 42 sources, 32 active:
  • Tools, 32:
    • Pipeline & compression: cheetah-texture-packer, ezspritesheet, gdx-texture-packer-gui, imagealpha, pnggauntlet, pngyu, snowb-bmf, squoosh, svgcode, vtracer, tilesplit.
    • Editors & creation: normalpainter, nebula-forge, sprite-fusion, sprite-fusion-pixel-snapper, graphicsgale, multipaint, paint-net, palette-extractor, piskel, rexpaint, tilemancer, rx-pixel-editor, spritemate, pixel-composer, fracplanet.
    • Music tools, following the Furnace/LMMS precedent: famistudio, dn-famitracker, milkytracker, sunvox, jfxr.
    • Godot 4 add-ons: folded-paper-engine.
  • 2d: iconmonstr, reiners-tilesets, spritelib, graphicburger-mobile-game-gui.
  • 3d: textureking.
  • shaders-vfx: nixie-fx.
  • audio: octave-ui-sounds, pacdv, soundbible, budgetpixel-sfx.
• Needs-review, with the reason:
  • cheetah-texture-packer: LGPL v3 text, but "only" or "or later" is not stated.
  • ezspritesheet: GPL-3 plus an EULA credit clause.
  • pngyu: "BSD" with no clause count.
  • pnggauntlet: the full terms are only inside the installer.
  • multipaint: no licence anywhere.
  • fracplanet: the GPLv2 badge disagrees with the v3-or-later headers.
  • textureking: bans redistribution "combined with another product".
  • pacdv: games are never named.
  • soundbible: licence is per file, including NC.
  • budgetpixel-sfx: AI-generated, and the licence changed on 2026-09-23.
• Vocabulary: licences GPL-3.0-only, CPL-1.0, LGPL-3.0 and BSD were added. LGPL-3.0 and BSD have no SPDX id: their spdx_ambiguous note says to record the precise value once the project states it. Formats AIFF and BMP were added.
• Placement: Pixel Composer and Fracplanet go in tools, following material-maker and gaea. Octave links its GitHub repo, because raisedbeaches.com is http only and raisesound.com is parked.
• Rejected, do not re-research without news. The full reasons are in the local RESEARCH/reject-log.md.
  • Unclear provenance or no licence:
    • Live Normal: app gone.
    • GameAsset.net: scraped, no operator.
    • 420 RPG icons: based on commercial game art.
    • nidorx/matcaps, Charas, Canyon Terrain Editor, AudioSauna, Voxelle Desktop: no licence or terms.
    • blender-models.com: per-model licences, including NC.
  • Restricted or duplicate:
    • DEM.Net: revenue-capped MIT.
    • gamesounds.xyz: mirror of sonniss-gdc.
    • Sprite Sheet Builder: output ownership not stated.
    • Vexlio SVG to PNG: paid-app funnel.
    • Ink: out of scope.
  • Dead: Pixelicious, Littera, PixelChart, Clara.io, ZBrushCoreMini, ShoeBox, PNGoo, Overlap2D, Sculptris, Sproxel, MadTracker, musagi.
  • Paid or freemium: TexturePacker, TinyPNG, Cascadeur, Aseprite and 13 others.
• Contributor PR #52 (3dtexel): merged; the submitter disclosed they are the publisher. Both Evidence quotes were re-read live on 2026-09-30. The entry covers only the free CC0 library. The site's AI and premium sections (3DTexel License: credit, no resale) are excluded, per docs/ai-assets.md. Counts conflicted with the import above and were regenerated with sync-counts (377).
• Next run: normalpainter's last push is 2023-10-15, so it becomes maintenance: inactive after 2026-10-15.

2026-09-26 (open issues sweep: #36 to #47)

The ten issues left open after the review, on the issues-sweep branch.

• Tags (#36): tags no longer restate the licence, the credit requirement or the entry's own publisher. 124 entries lost such a tag (cc0 40 more after #49, ofl 20, open-source 19, kenney/quaternius/kaykit/blender-studio and others). Licence tags are retired in site/value-aliases.json (V19); V21 rejects a tag equal to the entry's publisher. Search now weights publisher like a tag. Decided: a varies entry lists its licence mix in the body, not in tags.
• Formats (#37): site/format-vocabulary.json is the closed list (117 values in use); V20 rejects anything else. Its groups drive the Format filter. Kept: model (piper-plus, whose page names no container) and various (three aggregators).
• Filters (#45): Licence (families in license-vocabulary.json, every value in exactly one) and Format selects, in the URL as ?licence= and ?format=.
• Shortlist (#47): a star on cards and entry pages (localStorage fgda:shortlist), a panel with CREDITS.md / CREDITS.txt download. owes() moved to site/lib/owes.mjs (no imports, copied to dist/owes.js) so the stack pages and the shortlist share it; it gained a notices bucket for MIT/OFL-type licences.
• Maintenance (#42): optional maintenance: archived | inactive (V22), a badge and an entry-page row. Set from the GitHub API on 11 sources: archived glitch-archive, meta-animated-drawings, microsoft-movebox; inactive (no push in 3 years) dcss-tiles, sparklin-superpowers, instant-meshes, quadriflow, creature-2d-runtimes, gdquest-3d-mannequin, microsoft-rocketbox, godot-psx-style-demo. check-links.mjs reports a GitHub source whose state disagrees with the field (the first local run found godot-psx-style-demo, 3.01 years).
• Categories (#38): the rule is written in catalog/README.md (by main content; single-purpose creation tools sit with their content; mixed libraries by main kind). So the character creators and capture tools stay put, HDRI publishers stay in environment and BlendKit in 3d. Moved: nasa-3d-resources to 3d, nasa-image-video-library to video.
• Re-verified (#40): all ten July needs-review entries re-read. Now active: fab-megascans-standard, fmod-studio (credit line and splash logo required). Facts changed: opengameart commercial true, freesound commercial varies. Still open, with the question in Notes: lospec (per-palette terms), convology-xt (terms behind the download form), godot-shaders and opengameart (credit per upload), freesound (credit per sound), material-maker-gallery (per-item licence script-rendered), wwise (game EULA not public), charmorph (AGPL reach into exported meshes).
• Added (#43): 15 sources (Godot Engine, TrenchBroom, Ogmo Editor, func_godot, BeepBox, Bosca Ceoil Blue, Furnace, OpenMPT, Synfig, OpenToonz, Pencil2D, Kenney Animated Characters, Kenney Fonts, Monogram, Dareful); GPL-2.0-only added for Pencil2D. Skipped, do not re-research without news: DragonBones (site unreachable), Life of Vids (unreachable), Mazwai (redirects to Freepik). Music and animation editors follow the tools/ precedent (LMMS, Krita), not animation/. A "Request an asset / report a gap" issue form (label gap) now feeds the stack Gaps sections.
• Left: #41 (the remaining 2D fields need someone to open the files) and #3 (branch protection, deferred by the maintainer).

2026-09-26 (repo review and issue fixes)

A full review of code, site, catalog data and docs filed issues #1 to #47; this run fixed most of them on the review-fixes branch, one commit per issue or per interlocked group.

• CI: no push path filters (stacks-only pushes were neither validated nor deployed), Node 24 from .nvmrc, current action majors, Dependabot for actions, Pages calls ci.yml instead of repeating it, and a weekly link check (links.yml, site/check-links.mjs) that opens one correction issue. First run: 317 checked, none dead, moved or stale; 7 to 8 sites refuse robots.
• Build and checks: one frontmatter parser (site/lib/frontmatter.mjs) for build and validate, which had drifted; summaries keep literal _ and # (five changed); the build fails on an unreadable entry instead of dropping it. New checks: V16 url scheme, V17 category sets (folders, config, issue form), V18 heading anchors, V19 retired spellings (site/value-aliases.json); real calendar dates (the shared isRealDate is from a contributor's PR, #48, merged first); Evidence dates inside URLs no longer count; a day of time-zone slack. Renderer: parens in link hrefs, misnested emphasis, unique heading ids.
• Tooling: package.json scripts (npm run check), site/new-entry.mjs, site/sync-counts.mjs (every restated count in one command).
• Site: word-start search with name and tag hits first, rows toggled rather than rebuilt, focus kept after removing a filter, h4 card titles, contrast and touch targets, URL params validated, deferred scripts, a visible per-file note on Commercial OK, a folding filter panel on phones, back-to-results breadcrumb, 404 suggestions, sitemap link.
• Catalog (metadata only): removed the leaked r04 tag (15 entries); merged subcategory synonyms (tiles, pixel-art, ir, gui, base-mesh, public-domain as a subcategory); one spelling for duplicate tags and formats; publisher on six entries; three URLs moved to durable pages.
• Catalog (licence facts, re-read live 2026-09-26): material-symbols, ms-building-footprints and microsoft-rocketbox no longer ask for on-screen credit; their licences (Apache-2.0, CDLA-Permissive-2.0, MIT) need the licence text kept, and none of the publishers asks for more. Two 2D fields set where the page says so (bondoki-rotating-gems 52x52, lpc-revised-basics 3/4 view).
• Deliberately not changed: charge-materials and blender-ellie-poses keep a bare CC-BY: Blender's card says only "CC-BY", and guessing a version would be a licence claim. Fonts are not self-hosted: that would commit third-party binaries. No check yet for notice-only licences marked credit-required: nasa-3d-resources would need its credit wording re-read first.
• Still open for a person: #3 (branch protection), #36 (licence and publisher tags), #37 (a canonical format list), #38 (category moves), #40 (re-verify needs-review entries), #41 (the rest of the 2D fields: the sources do not state them), #42, #43, #45, #47.
• Search engines (2026-09-26): the site is a verified URL-prefix property in Google Search Console (HTML file site/public/google55e16d8bc56aeb36.html; keep it) and was imported into Bing Webmaster Tools, where the sitemap read Success with 324 URLs. Submit the sitemap by its full URL: /sitemap.xml resolves to the host root and 404s.
• Also merged: #48 (a contributor's impossible-date fix, merged first) and closed #50 (the same publisher change as #49). The link-check workflow ran once on GitHub: clean.
• Next highest-value action: the third full review on or after 2026-10-17. Check the Search Console sitemap row reads Success, and look at the ten open issues.

2026-09-25 (outreach)

Sub-project E, the items that reach outside the repo, each approved by the maintainer first.

• Repository description set with gh repo edit, without the em dash: "Curated catalog of free, commercially usable game assets, libraries and tools. Each licence recorded from its source with the date it was read. Links only, nothing rehosted."
• Pull requests opened, one line each, placed alphabetically, disclosing that the maintainer runs the catalog: ellisonleao/magictools#418 (Graphics > Assets/ Placeholders, +1), Kavex/GameDev-Resources#81 (Multiple Graphic Collections, +1), Calinou/awesome-gamedev#98 (Assorted Assets with reference 459, +4). The last list accepts only freedom-respecting material; the PR says the catalog links to sources under various licences and that its own metadata is CC0, and may be declined.
• Still for the maintainer: upload docs/images/readme/og-card.png as the social preview (Settings > General > Social preview); GitHub has no API for it.
• Also fixed: the entry pages spec now names site/lib/lib.test.mjs as the home of its renderer tests (c9c2bb2).
• Next highest-value action: the third full review on or after 2026-10-17. Check the three pull requests for maintainer comments before then.

2026-09-25 (README first screen)

Sub-project D from the site brainstorm, one commit (d76ec59), a bounded change agreed in conversation (no spec).

• The top of the README now leads with one line on what the catalog is and what each entry records, then the routes: the site ("Browse 319 sources", still checked by the validator), the five starter stacks, the licence freshness page, the master index and the licence guide, and a dated "Recent" line. The image showcase moved below "Start here", unchanged.
• No counts or ages that go stale were added: the freshness figures stay on the site, which rebuilds weekly. The "Recent" line is updated by hand with each release.
• A claim was narrowed before commit: "each with its licence quoted from the source" holds only for active entries, so the line says every entry records the licence and the date it was read, and active entries quote the source.
• Measured on github.com at 1280x800 with the README scrolled to its top: the Browse link, all five stack links, the freshness link and the Recent line sit within the first 350px.
• Next highest-value action: the third full review on or after 2026-10-17. Sub-project E (social preview image, repo description, awesome-list submissions) needs the maintainer's own clicks; the text can be prepared on request.

2026-09-25 (licence freshness)

Sub-project C from the site brainstorm, built from docs/design/2026-09-25-licence-freshness-design.md in five commits (241af04..749860a). No catalog entry changed and no verified moved.

• What shipped. A line under the homepage hero, "Checked within 180 days: 317 of 317. Older than a year: 0. Oldest check: 2026-07-19 (68 days). As of 2026-09-25", and /freshness/: the same line, the 76 entries checked on the build day or in the 30 days before it, and every entry oldest first. A "Licence freshness" footer link on every page, a sitemap entry (324 URLs) and a line in llms.txt. The buckets are the cards' own; deprecated entries are not counted.
• Weekly rebuild. pages.yml also runs Mondays at 06:17 UTC, so the ages move when nothing is pushed. GitHub pauses schedules in a public repository after 60 days without activity; a manual run from the Actions tab restarts them.
• Final review. Two fixes in 749860a: the homepage cards now age by the build time, like the prerender and the line (with the visitor's clock 60 days ahead a card read "128d ago" beside a line saying 68 days; now both say 68), and the recent-checks wording counts the build day. Three minors deferred: the "read at its source" sentence still prints if an entry lacks a date (the validator prevents that); cancel-in-progress lets a scheduled run and a push run cancel each other (the newer run publishes); an undated row has no chip style.
• Measured. Locally: the line's link opens the page; no sideways scroll at 375px and every table cell keeps its label; no text below AA in either scheme at 1280 and 375; the page is complete without JavaScript (76 recent, 317 rows); zero console errors. Live: /freshness/ 200 with 317 rows, sitemap 324, the homepage line and the llms line present, the schedule on main.
• Next highest-value action: the third full review on or after 2026-10-17, when the 61 entries checked on 2026-07-19 pass 90 days; rechecking them moves the freshness line. Then sub-project D, the README first screen.

2026-09-25 (recheck and deferred fixes)

Four commits (849af07..b63e3c3): the Smithsonian recheck, then the deferred minors from the entry pages and starter stacks reviews, each fix with a test that failed first.

• Smithsonian Open Access (849af07). The Open Access pages load again in a browser; scripted requests now get 403. The Terms of Use CC0 and commercial-use quotes are unchanged, the FAQ's CC0 sentence is added, and verified moves to 2026-09-25 on that reading.
• Renderer and links (ba8bf6e). Deprecation banners start the reason with a capital (freepd, purple-planet). Bare URLs stop at bold markers and code spans, keep a balancing paren, and <url> autolinks render. A malformed escape in a body link is a named error; a ?query on a relative link is kept. A page diff against the previous build changed only the two banners.
• Stack checks (1b677aa). The licence check also catches OFL, GPL, CC BY, any-case cc0, public-domain and royalty free as whole words, and skips link targets. A BOM or trailing spaces no longer break the frontmatter. Build and validator read one list of stack files; a stack in a subfolder fails both. llms-full.txt gives credit lines.
• Homepage and Copy (b63e3c3). A malformed #entry- link no longer stops the homepage script; starter-table links save the scroll position (Back: 745 to 745); a refused clipboard makes Copy all select only the credit lines.
• Still open from the reviews: the card's verified-date tooltip sits under the stretched link; a broken link in a stack's why sentence or gap names no line; the entry pages spec's Testing section names checks.test.mjs for tests that live in lib.test.mjs.
• Next highest-value action: sub-project C, visible trust, per the brainstorm. Then the third full review on or after 2026-10-17.

2026-09-25 (starter stacks)

Sub-project A from the site brainstorm, built from docs/design/2026-09-24-starter-stacks-design.md in seven commits (10151a9..3724fbb). No catalog entry changed and no verified moved.

• What shipped. Five stacks in stacks/, one per task test: 2D pixel platformer, 2D top-down pixel game, 3D low-poly arena in Godot, first-person destruction, mobile puzzle. Each has a page at /stack/<id>/ with one pick per need and a "What this stack owes" panel computed from the picked entries. The homepage has a Starter stacks section, each picked entry's page lists "Used in", and the sitemap (323 URLs) and both llms files carry the stacks. Only the platformer stack owes a credit line (Eric Skiff), so only its page has Copy buttons.
• Gates. V15 (site/checks.mjs) runs in the validator and the build. It fails a pick that is missing, deprecated or malformed, and any title, task, lead, gap or why sentence that names a licence: a stack states no licence facts of its own. Proved by pointing a pick at freepd: both exit 1 naming stacks/2d-pixel-platformer.md:18.
• Writing the stacks. Every why sentence was checked against its entry; three were cut to the entry's own words (Bondoki's GIFs, VT323's uses, Tiled's "ortho"). The top-down stack's one gap restates task B's finding: no straight-down character set that turns in four directions (0 top_down entries tagged 4-directional).
• Final review. Two findings fixed in 3724fbb: the licence check now covers every line of prose in a stack, and four statements the entries do not record were removed (the platformer lead's credit claim and "drawn for a side view", which the UI pack is not; "works in any engine" twice; "match and combo effects"). Seven minors deferred: short licence names such as "OFL" pass the check; link targets inside a why sentence are scanned; a BOM on the frontmatter line gives a misleading error; the Copy all fallback selects labels as well as credit lines; the validator walks stacks/ recursively while the build reads the top level; a broken link in a why sentence names no line; llms-full.txt lists credits by entry name without the line.
• Measured. Locally: five homepage links 200, Copy passes the credit line to the clipboard, pages complete without JavaScript, no sideways scroll at 375px, no text below AA in either scheme, zero console errors. Live: five stack pages 200, sitemap 323 URLs, ## Starter stacks in llms.txt, three "Used in" links on Kenney UI Pack, homepage link to the platformer page and its Copy button work.
• Next highest-value action: sub-project C, visible trust (freshness panel, recently added and re-verified lists), per the brainstorm. The Smithsonian recheck and the third full review on or after 2026-10-17 still stand.

2026-09-24 (entry pages)

Sub-project B from the site brainstorm, built from docs/design/2026-09-24-entry-pages-design.md in eleven commits (fee59c1..a5403a4). No catalog entry changed and no verified moved.

• What shipped. Every entry has a page at /entry/<id>/ with its full body, a facts panel, the credit line with a Copy button, and links to the source, the file on GitHub and a prefilled correction issue. Deprecated entries get a banner and noindex. The sitemap lists 318 real pages. llms.txt and llms-full.txt index the 317 visible entries. Homepage cards are now whole-card links; the entry dialog is gone and old #entry-<id> links redirect to the page.
• Gates. The build fails, naming the file and line, on markdown the renderer does not support or on a relative link to a missing file. It also checks every generated page for leaked markdown, one h1, a canonical link and links that resolve. Tests: site/lib/lib.test.mjs, 101 assertions, run in both workflows.
• Measured locally. Card corner click and touch tap open the page. Back restores the filter and scroll position (difference 0), and a fresh visit starts at the top. No sideways scroll at 375px. No text below AA contrast in either scheme. Zero console errors. Pages work without JavaScript.
• Final review. Four findings fixed in a5403a4, each with a test that failed first: escaped quotes showed as \" on four evidence pages; the ccmixter credit line copied with backslashes (a frontmatter parsing bug that predates this work); llms-full.txt had repo-relative links and cut summaries; the scroll position came back on an ordinary link to the homepage. Seven minor findings are deferred: bare-URL edge cases no entry uses yet; a malformed % stops the homepage script (in an #entry- link) or crashes the build without a file name (in a body link); the freepd banner's reason starts in lower case; starter-table links do not save the scroll position; the card's verified-date tooltip sits under the stretched link; the spec's Testing section names checks.test.mjs where the renderer tests live in lib.test.mjs.
• Measured live. /entry/kenney-ui-pack/ 200 with its Notes; sitemap 318 URLs; both llms files 200, llms-full.txt with 0 relative links; the old-link redirect, card click and touch tap all work on the deployed site.
• Next highest-value action: sub-project A, starter stacks, from the same brainstorm. The Smithsonian recheck and the third full review from the previous section still stand.

2026-09-24 (three more batches)

The previous section's next action, then two chosen on the maintainer's "your call".

• E, Google Fonts (4af52bf). Each family's OFL.txt in google/fonts names "The Project Authors", never Google Fonts. publisher removed from six fonts; each entry now quotes its exact copyright line (the notice OFL requires you to ship) and the designer from Google's METADATA.pb. material-symbols became Google (its README: "official icon sets from Google"). V7 now treats Google Fonts as a distributor.
• F, link sweep (no catalog change). All 319 URLs fetched: 305 return 200, none redirect to another domain. The 14 others are the known bot blocks plus Pexels and Pixabay video; all load in a browser except one. Smithsonian Open Access returns a server error (500) on /openaccess and /openaccess/faq while si.edu itself is up: a section outage, not a dead link. Entry unchanged; recheck next run. Results in _scratch/reviews/linkcheck-2026-09-24.json.
• G, relative dates (e21d7be). 78 notes in 62 entries said "this session", "this run" or "this pass". Each now carries the author date of the commit that wrote it, taken with git blame in the author's timezone; that matched every date already in the same lines. A first pass used UTC and was off by a day for evening commits, caught before writing. No quotation changed and no verified moved.
• Pre-existing em dashes remain in many older entries. They predate the review passes and the style rule's threshold treats them as reported, not defects; a mechanical sweep would rewrite prose in over a hundred files and is left to the maintainer.
• Next highest-value action: recheck Smithsonian Open Access; if /openaccess still errors at the next run, note it in the entry and look for the current URL. Then the third MODE=full review on or after 2026-10-17.

2026-09-24 (four batches)

The previous section's next action, then three more. One commit per batch.

• A, older OpenGameArt downloads (4c8e212). The four OGA entries added before 2026-09-23 had their downloads opened. No licence file contradicted a page, but two entries were wrong:
  • congusbongus-footsteps-surfaces: the credit line named only congusbongus, while the pack's own license.txt files credit six CC BY 3.0 Freesound authors; formats said WAV (it is 78 OGG files); the surface list claimed snow, which is not in the pack.
  • lpc-revised-basics: all 39 items in the bundled Credits files are OGA-BY, so the no-share-alike option covers everything; commercial was varies though all three offered licences allow commercial use. Now true, with the page's seven authors in the credit line.
• B, OpenGameArt as publisher (bf54aa2). CONTRIBUTING said "never the host" and listed OpenGameArt as a publisher group in the same paragraph. Removed from four entries; V7 now rejects it as a generic host, and skips the one-publisher-per-domain rule on opengameart.org and archive.org, where each upload has its own rights holder.
• C, Envato's Acceptable Use and Fair Use policies (0c13437). The last unread documents behind the Mixkit entries. Relevant to games: no AI training on assets; no content promoting the supply of weapons or gambling; assets depicting "sensitive topics" only for educational, informational, journalistic or advocacy use; and a "looks or feels like" catch-all. Games are not named. mixkit-stock-video unchanged.
• D, re-audit (a7712f7). Everything since the second full run passes the audit script. One real finding: V13 never checked tags, and seven singular/plural clash groups had built up (one from yesterday's own work). Fixed on 7 entries; V13 now covers tags; site search lets a plural query match a singular tag so nothing is lost.
• Recorded, not changed: publisher: Google Fonts on seven fonts. Google Fonts distributes fonts whose copyright usually sits with the designers, which reads like the "distributor that does not hold the rights" CONTRIBUTING rules out; but Google commissions some families. Deciding needs each font's copyright line, not a blanket rule.
• Next highest-value action: read the copyright line of each Google Fonts entry Done as batch E in the section above. And set publisher to the holder it names, or unset it where the holder is a project of many authors. Then the third MODE=full review on or after 2026-10-17.

2026-09-23 (parallax and gems)

The previous section's next action: a layered parallax source, then match-3 gems. One commit, 5bd86a1. Entry count 315 to 319 (2D 54). Both new task tests now pass.

• Added, each archive downloaded to measure it and to read any bundled licence: ansimuz-industrial-parallax and gustavo-saraiva-city-parallax (publisher-stated parallax layers, both CC0), bondoki-rotating-gems and sylly-gem-match-3 (match-3 gems, both CC0). The two parallax sets carry camera_perspective: side_scroller.
• New lesson, from a rejected candidate: GrumpyDiamond's Parallax Mountain Background shows CC0 on its OpenGameArt page, but the licence file inside its download says "cc-BY-3.0" and asks for credit. Not added. The OGA licence field is the uploader's claim; a bundled licence file can contradict it, and only opening the archive shows that. Every OGA entry added in this session had its download opened (Bondoki ships loose GIFs with no licence file, which the entry says); older OGA entries were not, and are worth the same check.
• Also rejected: CraftPix's OGA parallax sets (OGA-BY 3.0, credit required, and listed as teasers for paid packs) and "3 Parallax Backgrounds" (GPL 3.0, which is a poor fit for art in a closed game).
• publisher left unset on the four OGA entries: two existing opengameart.org entries carry publisher: OpenGameArt, and V7 requires one publisher per domain.
• Next highest-value action: open the archives of the older OpenGameArt entries Done as batch A of the 2026-09-24 section above. And compare any bundled licence file with the licence field, following the GrumpyDiamond finding. The OGA entries added before today were checked against the page only. Then the third MODE=full review on or after 2026-10-17.

2026-09-23 (new task tests)

The previous section's suggestion: walk tasks the catalog had not been tested against. One commit, 6990bea. Entry count 310 to 315 (2D 50, Audio 30).

• Task D, a 2D pixel platformer: passes, with two soft spots. Seven side-scroller packs, animated characters and enemies, Tiled and LDtk, pixel fonts, SFX generators. Leave points: no chiptune music ("chiptune" found only the SFX generators), and no source whose publisher states it includes parallax background layers.
• Task E, a mobile puzzle game: failed on the core art. UI, UI sounds, particles and fonts were covered, but "puzzle", "casual", "gem" and "dice" returned nothing relevant and "card" returned nothing card-game related.
• Added, each licence read at source and each archive downloaded to the scratchpad to measure its contents (nothing but metadata committed): kenney-puzzle-pack-2, kenney-playing-cards-pack, kenney-boardgame-pack (all CC0), subspaceaudio-5-chiptunes (CC0, confirmed by the author's own INFO.txt as well as the OGA field) and eric-skiff-resistor-anthems (CC-BY 4.0, games named, credit line stored). Every gap search now returns a real source.
• Stated limits: Puzzle Pack 2 is brick-breaker and pipe art, not match-3 gems; the entry says so. The Kenney puzzle-pack URL is a 404; "Puzzle Pack 1" exists and was not added.
• Parallax is still open. Sunny Land's comments say its backgrounds suit parallax, but its own feature list does not mention backgrounds, so no tag was added. Commenters are not evidence.
• Caught before commit: "the kind that fill mobile stores" (marketing voice), "title themes, level tracks and slower pieces" for an album not listened to, and "smooth vector style" inferred from an SVG folder. All removed or reduced to what was measured.
• Next highest-value action: a layered parallax background source Done in the parallax and gems section above, with match-3 gems. The one leave point left from task D. Look for a publisher-stated CC0 or CC-BY set of separate background layers; if none states it, record the gap rather than tagging a pack on a commenter's word. After that, match-3 gem art for task E.

2026-09-23 (binding documents)

The previous section's next action: read the full Pixabay Content License and the Mixkit User Terms. One commit, 71a5abc, four entries.

• Pixabay: the full licence is section 5 of the Terms of Service (the old /service/license/ URL now redirects to the summary). The grant is irrevocable, worldwide and royalty-free, to "download, use, copy, modify or adapt". Games are never named. What carries a game is the Standalone definition: content combined with other media into "a 'new' creative work" is not standalone. The entries and the guide now state that as the basis rather than asking the reader to confirm it.
• New Pixabay facts: content published before 9 January 2019 is CC0 (section 4); the prohibited uses include political contexts and portraying people as ill, which matters for stock faces in horror or hospital scenes. pixabay-audio verified moved to today with three dated quotes.
• Mixkit User Terms: 18 or over only; no mass downloading or scraping; nothing "on a stock or inventory basis"; copies sold only after alteration and combination. Nothing about games, so mixkit-stock-video stays needs-review: the terms neither add the word nor exclude games.
• Still unread: Mixkit's Acceptable Use Policy, which the User Terms bind items to.
• Next highest-value action: none that needs doing now. The one unread document is Mixkit's Acceptable Use Policy, a conduct policy unlikely to move either Mixkit entry. The next substantive run is a third MODE=full review on or after 2026-10-17, when the 73 entries verified in July cross 90 days and the age distribution first changes. Until then, new sources are the best use of a pass: pick a task the catalog has not been tested against (a 2D platformer, or a mobile puzzle game) and walk it the way the first run walked its three.

2026-09-23 (video sources)

The previous section's next action: video, one entry. One commit, 8f3955b. Entry count 305 to 310; video 1 to 6.

• Added, each licence read at source in a browser today: pexels-videos, pixabay-videos, coverr (all active), mixkit-stock-video and prelinger-archives (both needs-review).
• No video source names games. The three active ones are general grants (use, copy, modify, commercially, no credit) whose exclusions do not touch shipping inside a game; each entry says that is the basis, rather than claiming a games sentence exists. Pexels at least names apps.
• Mixkit is the catalog's clearest game-versus-video case. On one licence page, the Sound Effects Free License lists "Video games" and the Stock Video Free License does not. Stock video stays needs-review on that omission alone; the guide now cites the pair instead of the stale "Mixkit is video-first" line.
• Prelinger: the archive's own FAQ says "DO NOT ASSUME" its films are public domain. Only films carrying the Creative Commons public-domain dedication are free; 28 of the 30 most-downloaded carry it (Internet Archive search API). Credit is "delighted if", neither required nor waived, so attribution_required is unknown.
• Caught before commit: Coverr was first described as "smaller than Pexels" and "skewing towards lifestyle", then as the only source with an AI rule; Pexels "provides no releases"; Pexels "the largest library". None was read at a source, and Pexels' terms ban scraping for machine learning too. All removed or reworded.
• Not read, and named in the entries: the Mixkit User Terms (cited by both Mixkit licences as holding "important limits"), and the full Pixabay Content License (the page rendered no licence body; the entries quote the summary).
• Next highest-value action: read the two binding documents the entries could not: Done in the binding documents section above. the Mixkit User Terms and the full Pixabay Content License. Both licences point to them for limits, and between them they govern four entries (mixkit-sfx, mixkit-stock-video, pixabay-audio, pixabay-videos). Either could settle Mixkit video's games question, or add a restriction to the three entries now marked active.

2026-09-23 (maintainer decisions)

The maintainer took the recommended default on all three open decisions. One commit, 13a67e3. Nothing is parked any more.

• og:image: docs/images/readme/og-card.png, a 1200x630 screenshot of the site's first screen (57 KB), taken from the live page with the scrollbar hidden and only whole table rows showing. build.mjs copies it into dist and emits og:image (with size and alt), twitter:card summary_large_image and twitter:image; without the file it falls back to the old summary card. Retake it when the hero changes (noted in site/README.md).
• data.json: kept and documented in site/README.md as the public JSON: top-level keys, entry fields, regeneration on every push, and the caveat that licence facts are as current as each verified date.
• camera_perspective / grid_dimensions: 2D and UI only, stated in TEMPLATE and CONTRIBUTING. All 52 entries that set either field are in 2d, so no data changed.
• Next highest-value action: video, the one category that fails any task test. Done in the video sources section above. It has a single entry (destockd, a deliberate seed per the first run). A developer wanting free stock footage for a trailer, a menu background or an in-game screen has to leave the catalog. Source 3 to 5 candidates, opened and quoted, with the game-versus-video distinction from docs/game-vs-video-licensing.md in mind: a clip licensed for YouTube is not automatically licensed to ship inside a game.

2026-09-23 (formats cleanup)

The previous section's next action: formats values that are not formats. One commit, 40a6010, 20 entries.

• Removed where real formats were already listed: many, runtime, shaders, spreadsheet, Kinect, model (beside ONNX), config, examples, binary.
• Software with no file format of its own now names a delivery type: desktop-app (5 entries), mobile-app, cli (2); JS API became the JavaScript target.
• Moved to tags: windows, macos, ios, heightfield, and variable as variable-font on 5 fonts (Inter's existing variable tag renamed to match).
• CONTRIBUTING now defines four kinds of formats value (file formats, engine or language targets, delivery types, various for aggregators) and no longer claims every extension is upper case, which gdshader, tmx and ktx2 already contradicted.
• Nothing invented: Gaea and Piper name no output format in their entries, so they get a delivery type rather than a guessed file type.
• Not enforced by a check. The delivery-type list is short and could become a V13-style vocabulary later if it drifts.
• The review queue is now empty of work that does not need the maintainer. What is left is three decisions, carried since the first run.
• Next highest-value action: the three maintainer decisions Taken in the section above, all at the recommended default. With a recommended default for each so a yes is enough:
  • og:image: a first-party 1200x630 PNG of the site under docs/images/readme/, the path the validator already allows for first-party stills. Hard rule 3 covers third-party binaries, not the project's own screenshot.
  • data.json (297 KB, unused by the page): keep it and document it in site/README.md as the catalog's public JSON endpoint. Removing it breaks anyone already using it.
  • camera_perspective: keep it 2D-only, and say so in TEMPLATE. characters and 3d have no perspective in the 2D sense, and the View filter already explains itself.

2026-09-23 (plural subcategories)

The previous section's next action: the five singular/plural subcategory pairs. One commit, 48d3d4d, because the stricter check fails without the data fix.

• Kept the more common form of each, changing 15 entries: characters (9 over 7), environment (32 over 4), interior (7 over 1), tileset (8 over 2), vectors (2 over 1). The characters/character split was close; it is recorded in CONTRIBUTING so the next contributor does not reopen it.
• V13 now folds a trailing "s". Checked first against every formats and subcategories value in the catalog: the only hits were these five pairs, so no false positives today. One fixture added (52 assertions); a mutation on a real entry (kaykit-character-animations back to character) fails the validator.
• Process note: the mutation test was reverted with git checkout, which also reverted the uncommitted fix in that file. Caught by re-reading the file before commit. Revert a mutation with the inverse edit, not a checkout, while other changes are uncommitted.
• Next highest-value action: the formats values that are not formats Done in the formats cleanup section above. (examples, many, runtime, windows, macOS, iOS, library, binary and similar). Move each to tags where it carries meaning, delete it where it does not, and say in CONTRIBUTING that platforms are tags. Small, but they show up in the search haystack and on entry pages as if they were file types.

2026-09-23 (Search button)

The previous section's next action: make the floating button land where it focuses. One commit, 4c4a111.

• The button said "Top", scrolled to the page header, then focused the search box about 1,600px lower. It is now "Search": it scrolls to the catalog section and focuses the box with preventScroll, so there is one scroll and the focus is on screen.
• Checked at 1280x900 with and without reduced motion, 375x800 and 800x400: search box on screen and focused every time, and typing filters immediately ("kenney", 54 of 305).
• Not changed: the button stays visible while the search box is on screen, because it shows by scroll depth (600px) and the catalog starts below that. Cosmetic.
• Next highest-value action: settle the five plural subcategory pairs Done in the plural subcategories section above. (character/characters, environment/environments, interior/interiors, tileset/tilesets, vector/vectors) by majority use, then let V13 fold a trailing "s" so a new variant cannot return. Check the check against the whole catalog before trusting it: plural folding is where false positives would come from.

2026-09-23 (after the second full run)

The second full run's next action: the sticky filter panel on phones. One commit (0585922, labelled batch E in the log; it is a site fix, not the prompt's additions batch).

• Fixed. On screens up to 640px wide or 600px tall the panel scrolls away with the page instead of pinning. Measured in touch emulation: at 375x800 the entries went from about 270px of screen to all 800px; at 800x400 (a phone on its side) they get all 400px (the old figure there was not measured). Desktop is unchanged: sticky, 228px.
• The panel's height also fed --sticky-h, which reserves space above permalink and category-jump targets. On phones that reserved 527px of empty space above the target. app.js now publishes 0 when the panel is not sticky: #entry- permalinks land 16px from the top on both small layouts.
• The Top button is now how a phone user gets the filters back. Checked: it returns with the search box visible and focused.
• Found, not fixed (pre-existing, same on the live site): on desktop, Top scrolls to the page header but focuses the search box about 1,600px further down, off screen. A keyboard user who then types is typing into a field they cannot see.
• Next highest-value action: make Top land where it focuses. Done in the Search button section above. Either scroll to the catalog controls rather than the page top, or stop moving focus. A few lines in app.js, and it is the last interaction defect on record. After that, the plural subcategory convention (five pairs) from the second full run.

2026-09-23 (second full run)

The fifteenth pass's next action: a fresh MODE=full run, measured from zero. Findings in _scratch/reviews/2026-09-23-findings.md; thresholds were written there before any script ran.

• Measured: 305 entries (275 active, 28 needs-review, 2 deprecated); commercial true 274, unknown 20, varies 9, false 2; 22 licence values, all in the vocabulary. Required fields 305/305. license_spdx 239, publisher 135. Every verified: under 90 days (the 73 July dates cross 90 on 2026-10-17). Every entry reaches data.json with no field dropped, and every entry has a listing row. Validator, build and tests exit 0.
• No licence defects found. 26 "commercial but mentions non-commercial" keyword hits were read by hand; all were "commercial and non-commercial" phrasing.
• Contrast measured on the live site in both schemes: 2,968 text nodes each, none below AA. Dialog focus trap, Escape and focus return pass. No horizontal scroll at 375px.
• Executed, one commit each, in the order A, C, B, D so B's checks ran clean:
  • A (a1b0ccb): 4 formats case clashes (6 entries) and 4 subcategories pairs (4 entries) normalised; CONTRIBUTING now states a spelling convention for both fields, which had none; em dashes removed from 2 entry lines added by review passes and from the site tagline, hero and footer.
  • C (e420bdc): godotsteam custom to MIT and active, read on Codeberg in a browser; the Steamworks SDK is stated as Valve's separate agreement. vroid-studio attribution unknown to false, from Article 13 of pixiv's VRoid Studio terms.
  • B (766e6b7): V13 rejects formats/subcategories values that differ only by case or punctuation; V14 rejects unknown licence, commercial or attribution on an active entry. 51 assertions across 14 checks; both also proved by mutating real entries.
  • D (ff120aa): nav and entry title links 20px to 44px on touch screens, via inline padding, so the layout does not move.
• Correction to the audit: it listed "active entries may lack Evidence" as a validator gap. validate.mjs already enforces that; only the unknown half was real.
• New defects found while executing, deferred by the no-scope-growth rule:
  • The sticky filter panel covers two thirds of a phone screen: 527px of an 800px viewport, pinned while scrolling, leaving about 270px for entries. Desktop: 228px.
  • Five plural subcategory pairs (character/characters, environment/environments, interior/interiors, tileset/tilesets, vector/vectors). A convention call.
  • formats values that are not formats (examples, many, runtime, windows, macOS, iOS, library, binary).
• Still needs the maintainer: og:image hosting, whether data.json (297 KB, unused by the page) is a public endpoint, the two camera_perspective scope questions.
• Next highest-value action: fix the sticky filter panel on phones. Done in the section above. It is the one finding that makes the live site worse to use for everyone on a phone, and the fix is contained: collapse the panel on small screens or stop it sticking there.

2026-09-23 (fifteenth pass, same session)

The fourteenth pass's next action: clear the bot-blocked backlog with a real browser (Playwright). Batch U, one commit.

• All 12 first-pass URLs load in a browser. None is dead. cloudcompare still answers 403 first and then serves the page after a challenge; the rest return 200. The 403/454 results in the first pass were bot blocks, as recorded.
• tenacity resolved: GPL-2.0-or-later. LICENSE.txt says "GNU GPL Version 2" with no election; the project README says "either version 2 of the License, or (at your option) any later version". A project-authored README sentence is exactly the evidence the second pass's parked rule accepts. The last unconfirmed GPL value is gone.
• musopen resolved to varies, and the Wayback 404 is explained: the licence URLs no longer exist. Licences are per recording. On Chopin's Op. 9 page, five recordings link the Public Domain Mark and one links CC BY-NC-SA 3.0. The site Terms of Use also carry a boilerplate "personal, non-commercial" clause for site materials; the entry reports it rather than resolving it. Stays needs-review.
• vroid-studio promoted to active, commercial: true. pixiv's guidelines allow commercial use including "games", state the base content "is not CC0", and bar building a character creator from VRoid output. The Terms article they cite was not found on pixiv's policies page, so attribution_required stays unknown.
• scan-the-world is now commercial: false. MyMiniFactory's Terms allow downloads "solely for your own non-commercial use" absent an agreement with the design's owner. No per-object licence rendered, so license stays unknown, needs-review.
• Mixkit's licence was readable without accepting cookies. The text is in the page behind the consent dialog. The twelfth pass's "accepting cookies is the owner's call" turned out not to be needed. The licence names video games, bans standalone redistribution "in a tool or template", and bans registering sounds with a rights management service. The audio README's "unchecked" Content ID line now quotes it.
• verified: moved on five entries, each with a dated Evidence quote from a page read today. godot-shaders and the other loading URLs kept their dates: they loaded, but their licence text was not re-read.
• Tooling note: a leftover serve process from the fourteenth pass locked site/dist and broke the build with EPERM. Stop preview servers by process, not only the task.
• Still open, and needing a person rather than a browser: the two camera_perspective scope questions, og:image hosting, and whether site/dist/data.json is a public endpoint. Smaller: VRoid's credit terms, Musopen's ToS clause, Scan the World's per-object licences.
• Next highest-value action: a fresh MODE=full run of the review prompt. Done in the second full run above. Fifteen passes have run against measurements taken on 2026-09-22 at 294 entries. The catalog is now 305 entries with new checks, guides and a changed site; re-measuring from zero is how the next pass avoids optimising against stale numbers.

2026-09-23 (fourteenth pass, same session)

The thirteenth pass's next action: re-run the first pass's task test. Same three tasks, walked from the site search and the category guides, recording each point where a stranger would leave.

• Task A, 3D low-poly arena with rigged characters and impact SFX in Godot 4: no leave point. Arena, characters, clips, first-person arms, weapons, impact SFX, UI, prompts, font, music and Godot add-ons are all active, and all but Mixamo and Sonniss are CC0/OFL/MIT. Friction, not a gap: the arms are FBX and .blend only, so they go through Blender before Godot, and the entry says so.
• Task B, 2D top-down pixel game with UI, prompts and a terminal font: passes, but the View filter misled. Both 4-directional CC0 character sets (ninja-adventure, armm1998-zelda-like) are isometric_3_4, so a stranger choosing View "Top-down" saw tiles and vehicles and no character that turns. Labels now say "Top-down, straight down" and "3/4 top-down, walls visible".
• Task C, first-person destruction with debris materials, industrial props and ambience: passes by the fracture route. Arms, fracture tools, industrial kits and ambience are found. Leave point found and fixed: searching "concrete" returned nothing, because no texture library named a material. Five libraries whose own pages list concrete, metal and brick now carry those tags; ShareTextures gets metal only, the one of the three its page shows. Texture Ninja and TextureCan were not tagged: one page showed none of the words, the other refused the request (406).
• The biggest leave point was the site, not the catalog. Search matched the query as one exact substring, so "first person", "top down" and "low poly" all returned zero while first-person, top-down and low-poly tags existed. Every task hit it. Now words match independently, hyphens read as spaces, and the perspective is searchable. Checked in a browser against the built site: "first person" 3, "top down" 14, "low poly" 15, "concrete" 5, no console errors. Bag-of-words matching is looser: "first person" also returns ccMixter, whose summary has both words. Accepted.
• Stale cross-reference fixed: the Toon Shooter entry still called itself the closest thing to first-person arms. It and the guns pack now link the arms entry.
• Batch T, one commit. verified: untouched throughout: tags and search are not licence facts.
• Deferred, unchanged: tenacity's licence, the two camera_perspective questions, Mixkit's licence text, and the first pass's 12 bot-blocked URLs.
• Next highest-value action: clear the bot-blocked backlog with a real browser. Done in the fifteenth pass above. tenacity (Codeberg 403), Mixkit (cookie wall; whether to accept cookies to read it is still the owner's call), and the 12 URLs that returned 403/454 in the first pass have all waited on "a browser-based check". This session has one.

2026-09-23 (thirteenth pass, same session)

The twelfth pass's next action: the two task-test gaps. Both now have entries.

• Batch S, first-person arms: characters/oga-fps-arms-rigged (CC0, OpenGameArt, 2015). Measured from the FBX: clavicle to hand on both sides, three-segment fingers and thumbs, hand.L.control / hand.R.control IK handles. No animations beyond a rig test, FBX and .blend only. Weak art, but it is the only rigged first-person arms source that checked out. Rejected: OGA "Low Poly FPS Rifle and Hands" (CC0, 2022) has one joint and static hands; a CC-BY 4.0 arms pack was not opened and is not listed.
• Batch S, debris: no free pre-fractured rubble pack turned up (Poly Haven has none), and fracturing your own meshes is the normal route, so the catalog lists the tools: blender-cell-fracture (GPL-3.0-or-later, from the extension manifest), godot-destruction-plugin, voronoishatter, godot-voxel-destruction (all MIT). The Godot 4 add-ons table gained three maintenance rows and a paragraph on the two routes.
• Stated as inference, not fact: VoronoiShatter's README names no Godot version; "4.4+" comes from the .uid files it ships. Voxel Destruction's optional Rust setup "will use prebuilt binaries" that are in neither the repository nor the release, so the entry says to find where they come from first.
• Caught before commit: a Notes line claimed the Cell Fracture page shows a bare "GPL-3.0"; the page says "v3.0 or later". Removed. The Jummit README's CC0 header was first read as a README-only licence; the README actually splits the repository, code MIT and all other files CC0. Rewritten to say so.
• Not added: ZachAR3/Destructibles-CSharp (MIT, needs Godot .NET, no releases). The Cell Fracture entry cites its 5 to 50 piece guidance.
• Deferred, unchanged: tenacity's licence, the two camera_perspective questions, Mixkit's licence text.
• Next highest-value action: re-run the first pass's task test end to end. Done in the fourteenth pass above. Every gap it found now has an entry or a guide; re-running it is the check that those answers hold up, and whatever still fails becomes the next batch.

2026-09-23 (twelfth pass, same session)

The eleventh pass's next action: audio/sfx. Every cluster measured in the seventh pass now has decision support.

• Batch R: "Choosing sound effects" in catalog/audio/README.md (14 SFX sources, 4 impulse-response packs), sorted by job, with the restrictions beyond credit that actually differ: Sonniss is media-production-only and bans AI training; Zapsplat's free tier is MP3 only; BigSoundBank's CC0 covers only files marked "Free and Royalty Free".
• The open question is answered: Content ID does reach sound effects, indirectly. Freesound's FAQ explains it: musicians register songs containing raw sounds from free libraries, so later videos using the same raw sound get matched, and processing a sound makes a match less likely. Zapsplat's licence acknowledges mistaken automated claims. The mechanism works on any widely downloaded sound, CC0 included.
• Impulse responses: shipping changes what you owe. Runtime convolution ships the IR file; Adventure Kid asks for credit when its IRs are redistributed "in software".
• Two claims caught before commit. The table attributed a no-redistribution term to Mixkit that is not on record. And Fesliyan's music policy (no YouTube monetisation, no livestreaming) was nearly attributed to its sound effects; that page is the music policy, and the separate SFX policy has none of those restrictions. Lesson: on a site that sells two things, find the policy for the thing you are cataloguing.
• Unchecked, stated as unchecked: Mixkit's licence text would not load behind a cookie consent dialog, and accepting cookies to get past it is not a review pass's decision. The README says "unchecked", not "not addressed".
• README "Start here" now links ten guides, including both audio ones.
• Deferred, unchanged: tenacity's licence, the two camera_perspective questions, Mixkit's licence text.
• Next highest-value action: the two task-test gaps still unsourced since the first pass: rigged first-person arms, and rubble / pre-fractured debris geometry. Done in the thirteenth pass above. The decision-support work is done; the catalog still cannot answer those two requests at all, and they came from the task test tied to the owner's own work.

2026-09-23 (eleventh pass, same session)

The tenth pass's next action: music. Two commits, one of them fixing a regression of my own.

• Batch Q: "Choosing game music" in catalog/audio/README.md, sorted by the two questions that decide it: is a credit owed, and will videos of the game be claimed.
• The finding: Content ID lands on your players, not on you. Only one of twelve music entries mentioned Content ID. Checked at each source: Incompetech's own page says claims follow when "the credit was placed in the video itself" rather than in the description text, so an in-game credit satisfies the licence but not YouTube, and every streamer needs the description credit. Pixabay's own guide says "many music composers, including those that share their work on Pixabay, have their content digitally fingerprinted", flaggable but not always flagged. ENDE forbids anyone registering its tracks. Soundimage, Tallbeard and Kenney say nothing; the table says "not addressed", which is not the same as safe. Notes added to three entries; no verified dates moved (not licence text).
• Pixabay blocks scripts, so its pages were read in a real browser. Worth remembering for other 403 sources: a browser read is still a primary-source read.
• Index fixes: the heading "Music (attribution usually required)" was false (four of six active sources owe nothing), and Zapsplat's † footnote sat under the wrong table.
• Regression fixed: V11 had been checking only the first listing table in each category README since batch K. Audio has three, tools has seven, so six tools sections and two audio sections were unchecked. Proved by reverting the mod-loader row to MIT, which validated clean. V11 now reads every | ID | table, with a fixture that puts drift in a second table. The widened check found no drift in the tables it had been skipping. Lesson: batch K proved V11 against single-table READMEs only. When a check changes how it finds its input, test it on the unusual shapes, not the common one.
• Deferred, unchanged: tenacity's licence, the two camera_perspective questions.
• Remaining measured cluster: audio/sfx (14).
• Next highest-value action: audio/sfx: done in the twelfth pass above, which also answered whether Content ID reaches sound effects (it does, indirectly).

2026-09-23 (tenth pass, same session)

The ninth pass's next action (tools/godot), plus a maintainer-requested README rewrite.

• Batch P: a Godot 4 add-on maintenance table in catalog/tools/README.md, read from each repository: licence, last commit, latest release, archived flag, Godot version.
• Licence reversal on godot-mod-loader, MIT to CC0. The entry linked Godot-Modding/loader, recorded MIT, and said that older drafts claiming CC0 "are wrong". The drafts were right. That repository is a placeholder: a one-line README, a LICENSE and a docs folder, no code. The project is GodotModding/godot-mod-loader, confirmed by both Godot Asset Library listings and its own CC0 LICENSE. verified moved with three dated Evidence lines. Lesson worth keeping: an earlier pass "corrected" a true claim by verifying the wrong repository. A licence has to belong to the thing people actually download, so confirm the canonical source before reading its licence.
• Also found: GodotSteam's GitHub repo is archived (moved to Codeberg, still active); Creature 2D Runtimes is a Godot 3 runtime last touched in 2020, listed under a "Godot 4 add-ons" heading (now labelled); Waterways' default branch and only release are Godot 3, with Godot 4 on branches. Notes only on all three.
• Checked and left alone: Sky3D, scatter2d and gdquest-godot-shaders show NOASSERTION on GitHub, but their licence files are ordinary MIT and, for GDQuest, a documented MIT-code / CC-BY-NC-SA-art split that its entry already handles correctly.
• README rewritten around what a visitor is trying to do: a task-to-guide table linking the eight comparison guides, which the front page had never linked; an accurate field reference; a licence-guide table including fonts.md and geodata.md; and a section on what the validator actually enforces. Kept every badge and the three patterns check V6 validates. Rendered through GitHub's markdown API in README mode before commit, which caught four false claims.
• Style debt paid. The brief forbids em dashes in anything written into the repo, and this session had added them to 29 lines. Measured from the diff since the session began, so only this session's text was touched; 27 fixed, 2 left because they sit in pre-existing sentences.
• CONTRIBUTING corrected. It called listing an entry in its category README "optional", which the validator has always rejected, and told contributors to use any licence name, which check V1 has rejected since batch B. Both now match the validator.
• Deferred, unchanged: tenacity's licence, the two camera_perspective questions.
• Remaining measured clusters: audio/sfx (14), audio/music (11).
• Next highest-value action: the audio clusters, starting with music: music done in the eleventh pass above; audio/sfx remains.

2026-09-23 (ninth pass, same session)

Both of the eighth pass's next actions. Two commits.

• poly-pizza updated. The licence-label finding was re-checked before being written down: the first reading took the first licence string anywhere on each page, which can come from a related-model card. Read properly from each model's structured Licence field, with the creator confirmed as Quaternius on all eight, it holds: one model is CC-BY 3.0, seven are CC0 1.0, and the author's own site says CC0. The entry now says the licence is per file, not per author, and warns about the same page-reading trap. verified moved to 2026-09-23 because the entry's claim (licences vary per model) was read live today, with two dated Evidence lines, so V8 holds. Still needs-review.
• Batch O: catalog/characters/README.md gained "Choosing a rigged character source", sorted by licence first and then by engine-readiness.
• The finding: three sources, three skeletons. KayKit uses 41 joints with its own short names, weapon hand-slots and no finger bones; the Quaternius model uses a 53-joint Rigify rig with fingers; GDQuest's mannequin uses 45 joints with Unreal-mannequin-style names. Animations need retargeting between publishers, and finger animation retargeted onto KayKit is lost.
• microsoft-rocketbox gained notes from its README: four LODs, 417 animations, facial blendshapes (the only ones in the catalog), Unity-first tooling. Notes only.
• Caught before commit: a draft said every Blender Studio rig needs a login and Blender 5.0. The entries record that only for the Singularity rigs; Rain is a direct download. The Quaternius skeleton figures are also scoped to the model actually measured, not to the Universal Base Characters pack, which was not opened.
• Deferred, unchanged: tenacity's licence, the two camera_perspective schema and scope questions.
• Remaining measured clusters: audio/sfx (14), tools/godot (12), audio/music (11).
• Next highest-value action: tools/godot: done in the tenth pass above, which also found the mod-loader licence reversal.

2026-09-23 (eighth pass, same session)

Took the seventh pass's next action. Batch N. The 3D kit question, which earlier passes held back as a matter of art style, turned out to be mostly measurable.

• Executed: parsed the glTF/GLB of every model in Kenney's Modular Dungeon and Nature kits (368), every model in KayKit's Dungeon Remastered and Adventurers packs (235), and eight Quaternius models, then wrote Choosing between Kenney, KayKit and Quaternius into catalog/3d/README.md. Triangles, texturing, rigs, animation counts, height, file size and delivery, each from the files rather than the store pages.
• The finding that matters most is scale. Kenney Nature Kit trees are 1.33 m and rocks 0.32 m; Kenney's own Modular Dungeon walls are 4.2 m; Quaternius trees are 7 to 10 m. The Nature Kit is authored at a miniature scale and needs about 5x before it sits beside anything else. KayKit and Kenney dungeon walls agree within 5% (4.0 m, 4.2 m).
• Correction: kenney-nature-kit advised pairing it with the Quaternius Stylized Nature MegaKit "for denser stylized forests". Measured, that puts 1.3 m trees beside 7-10 m trees at a twentyfold density gap. Rewritten. Notes only; verified unchanged.
• New finding, logged rather than acted on, per the rule on scope: Poly Pizza labels the same author's work inconsistently. Of eight Quaternius models checked, seven showed "Public Domain" and one (Animated Base Character) showed "Creative Commons Attribution", while Quaternius itself releases the packs as CC0. That is direct evidence for the poly-pizza entry's needs-review status and belongs in its notes next run: an aggregator's per-file licence label cannot be trusted over the author's own statement.
• Method limits, stated in the README as well. Quaternius packs are served through itch, whose free-download flow would not issue a file outside a browser session (the signed key was rejected every time without browser cookies). The Quaternius figures come from eight models on Poly Pizza, so they are indicative, not pack-wide. KayKit ships official GitHub repos (KayKit-Game-Assets/*), which is why its sample is complete.
• Deferred, unchanged: tenacity's licence, the camera_perspective scope question for characters and 3d, the single-valued camera_perspective schema question.
• Remaining measured clusters: characters/rigged (14), audio/sfx (14), tools/godot (12), audio/music (11). The KayKit and Quaternius rig numbers from this pass already cover most of characters/rigged.
• Next highest-value action: add the Poly Pizza finding, then characters/rigged: both done in the ninth pass above.

2026-09-23 (site navigation, same session)

Maintainer-requested navigation and usability work, not a review pass. Batches L and M. Recorded here because it changes what the site promises and fixes a defect.

• Defect fixed: below 640px, .topnav a:nth-child(-n + 3) { display: none } hid Catalog, Starters and Guides, so the mobile primary nav contained only "GitHub". It predates this session. All four links now fit at 375px.
• L: the catalog is grouped under category headings with counts (default sort and no category filter only; other sorts render flat because grouping would hide the order asked for). Category chips show faceted counts under the other active filters. The chip for the section in view gets a separate "you are here" marker with aria-current; chips stay pure filters. Back-to-top, / to focus search, Esc to clear. Without JS the chips are prerendered as jump links to the group headings. Anchored targets clear the sticky filter bar via a measured --sticky-h and scroll-margin-top.
• M: previous/next inside the entry dialog, in on-screen order across group boundaries and within filters, with arrow keys, a "4 of 23" position, and focus returning to the entry you ended on. An entry opened from a permalink that the current filters exclude gets no pager, because there is no honest "next" for it.
• Both batches verified in a browser at 1200px and 375px in both colour schemes: every control at least 44px, WCAG AA on all new text, no overflow, no console errors.
• Parked, do not re-litigate: chips filter, they do not jump. Making one control both filter and navigate was considered and rejected in design. Grouping is deliberately conditional on the default sort.
• Next highest-value action for the catalog is unchanged from the seventh pass below: the 3D kit question (Kenney vs Quaternius vs KayKit).

2026-09-22 (seventh pass, same session)

Took the sixth pass's next action. Batch K. Re-measured before starting, and the ledger's own figure was wrong.

• The "eight uncovered clusters" carried forward since the second pass was stale: the tools comparison table from batch E already covers seven of the original ten. Counting clusters properly, by entries sharing a subcategory inside a category, found much larger ones nobody had looked at. Lesson for future passes: re-measure the deferred item before working it, because a count written three passes ago describes a catalog that no longer exists.
• Executed: three comparison tables, chosen by cluster size and by how little the licence column helps.
  • catalog/2d/README.md: Choosing a pixel tileset (10 sources). Sorted by grid size and projection, the two things that actually decide it.
  • catalog/3d/README.md: Choosing a PBR texture source (8 sources). Sorted by licence first: six are genuine CC0, sharetextures and freepbr are custom grants that permit shipping a game but restrict passing the textures on.
  • catalog/fonts/README.md: Choosing a pixel font (9 sources). Sorted by kind of retro, and by CJK coverage, which three have and the licence column cannot show.
• The 2D tileset table is one this session owed. Batch H added six pixel tile packs to a category that already had four, leaving ten CC0 sources that look interchangeable. Adding sources without adding a way to choose between them is a debt, and it is worth noticing that the same pass that closes a coverage gap can open a decision-support one.
• V11 reworked. The 3D table leads with the entry link, which made it structurally identical to a catalog listing row, and V11 produced seven false positives. It now finds the listing by its | ID | header rather than by row shape. To stop that from becoming a check that measures nothing if the header ever changes, a category README with entries and no such table is now itself an error. Both behaviours are fixtured and were re-proved by mutating the real catalog.
• Deferred, unchanged: tenacity's licence (Codeberg 403s automated requests), the camera_perspective scope question for characters and 3d, and the single-valued camera_perspective schema question from the sixth pass.
• Remaining clusters, now measured rather than guessed, largest first: 3d/environment (32), 3d/props (26), 3d/modular (17), characters/rigged (14), audio/sfx (14), tools/godot (12), audio/music (11), characters/animated (10). The 3D ones are really one question, Kenney vs Quaternius vs KayKit: three publishers holding 80 entries, and answering it well needs a view on art style and topology, not metadata.
• Next highest-value action: that 3D kit question. It is the largest cluster in the catalog, catalog/3d/README.md had no guidance at all until this pass, and a developer starting a 3D project hits it immediately.

2026-09-22 (sixth pass, same session)

Took the fifth pass's next action. Batch J. The 2D taxonomy is now as complete as it can honestly be.

• Executed: opened all three packs.
  • kenney-tiny-dungeon -> isometric_3_4. Walls carry a lit front face below the top surface and figures face the viewer.
  • ox72-dungeon-tileset -> isometric_3_4. Vertical brick wall face behind a floor plane, front-facing creatures. Matches its already-classified sibling.
  • kenney-1-bit-pack -> stays absent, and now says why. camera_perspective 28 -> 36 of 300.
• A real limit of the field, found by opening the archive. The 1-bit pack ships four official Kenney sample scenes: fantasy overworld, interior, urban and platformer. The fantasy sample is 3/4 with building facades; the platformer sample is a side-scroller built from the same tiles. The pack genuinely serves both, so no single value is correct. This is not missing data, it is a single-valued field meeting a multi-perspective tileset.
• Open schema question, deliberately not answered here. Should camera_perspective accept a list, or a multi value? Widening it changes what the View filter means for all 300 entries (does a side_scroller filter return a pack that merely can be used that way?), so it is the maintainer's call, not a detail to settle inside a tagging pass. For now the field stays absent on such packs, the reason is in the entry, and a multi-perspective tag makes it findable by search.
• Every 2D entry that can carry a single honest value now does. What remains absent is absent for a stated reason, which was not true before this pass.
• Deferred, unchanged: tenacity's licence (Codeberg 403s automated requests), the eight decision-support clusters without comparison lines, and the camera_perspective scope question for characters and 3d.
• Next highest-value action: the eight decision-support clusters: worked in the seventh pass above, where the count turned out to be stale. Three much larger clusters were covered instead.

2026-09-22 (fifth pass, same session)

Took the fourth pass's next action. Batch I. The original task-test gap is now closed, four passes after it was first measured.

• Executed: downloaded and opened the three character sheets, and recorded what each actually ships rather than what its description implies.
  • ninja-adventure: 4-directional. 64x112 per character on a 16px grid: four columns for down, up and both sides, seven rows of frames.
  • armm1998-zelda-like: 4-directional. 272x256 sheet of 16x32 frames, four facings, four-frame walk plus a sword set in each direction.
  • kenney-roguelike-characters: front-facing only. 918x203 on a 16px tile with 1px spacing: bodies, hair, clothing, armour, shields and weapons, every frame the front view. No side or back facings, no animation frames anywhere in the pack. Tagged 4-directional and front-facing so site search reaches them.
• Correction to the fourth pass. The kenney-roguelike-characters note claimed variants were "separate sprites rather than a layered paper doll". The sheet shows the opposite: it is a layered parts kit meant to be composited. What it lacks is turning, not layering. Fixed. The lesson is the same one the fourth pass recorded about perspective: the sheet answers questions the store page does not.
• verified: deliberately unchanged on all three. Frame layout is not licence text, and the findings sit in Notes rather than Evidence because an Evidence line in this repo means proof of licence and commercial stance.
• Sources opened: kenney_roguelike-characters.zip from the Kenney asset page, gfx_3.zip attached to the OpenGameArt submission, and content/character/*/sprite.png in pixel-boy/NinjaAdventure, the author's own game repo built from the itch pack. The itch download itself is behind a form, so the Ninja Adventure layout is verified from that repo rather than from the pack archive; a future run with a browser could confirm against the itch zip.
• Deferred, unchanged: tenacity's licence (Codeberg 403s automated requests), the eight decision-support clusters without comparison lines, the three deliberately untagged tile packs, and the camera_perspective scope question for characters and 3d.
• Next highest-value action: the three untagged tile packs: done in the sixth pass above. Two resolved to isometric_3_4; the 1-bit pack is genuinely multi-perspective and stays absent with a stated reason.

2026-09-22 (fourth pass, same session)

Sourcing, against the gap the View filter exposed. Batch H.

• Executed: 6 new 2D entries, all CC0 and all active. Entry count 294 -> 300. kenney-micro-roguelike (8x8, top_down), kenney-tiny-battle (16x16, top_down), kenney-tiny-town, kenney-roguelike-rpg-pack, kenney-roguelike-characters and armm1998-zelda-like (all isometric_3_4). top_down 1 -> 3, and two of the three are now active CC0 rather than a lone needs-review aggregator.
• Method worth repeating: perspective was decided by opening each pack's sample image, because no Kenney asset page states a projection in text. That is how the split was found. Micro Roguelike and Tiny Battle are genuinely orthographic; Tiny Town and the Roguelike/RPG pack draw facades above an overhead ground plane and are 3/4. Filing all of them as top-down because they are overhead RPG tiles would have been wrong, and reading only the descriptions would have produced exactly that error.
• The character half of the gap is still open. It was stated as "CC0 4-directional top-down character sprites" and nothing added here claims four-direction walk cycles. Kenney Roguelike Characters is front-facing 3/4 sprites with variants; the ArMM1998 submission says "Character with sword animation and character tamplet" without enumerating directions. Both entries say so in their notes. Confirming directional coverage means downloading and opening the sheets, which no pass has done.
• Deferred, unchanged: tenacity's licence (Codeberg 403s automated requests), the eight decision-support clusters without comparison lines, the three deliberately untagged tile packs, and the scope question about camera_perspective on characters and 3d.
• Next highest-value action: open the character sheets: done in the fifth pass above. Two of the three turn; the Kenney set does not.

2026-09-22 (third pass, same session)

Took the "next highest-value action" the first two passes both named. Batch G.

• Executed: the 2D taxonomy is populated and exposed. camera_perspective 11 -> 28, grid_dimensions 6 -> 11. Site gained a View filter with URL state (?view=side_scroller), the grid and perspective on every row, both fields in the entry dialog, and an active-filter chip. New check V12 enforces the documented vocabulary for all three optional fields, which TEMPLATE.md described and nothing had ever checked.
• Also fixed, found by reading the deployed payload rather than by any check: license_spdx was 0/294 in the built site. build.mjs never copied the field onto the entry object, so every SPDX identifier the catalog has recorded existed only in frontmatter and had never reached data.json, data.js or the page. Now 227/294 live. Worth noting the shape of this bug: validate.mjs measures frontmatter, build.mjs decides what ships, and nothing compares the two. Other fields could be dropped the same way and no check would notice.
• Method, and the constraint worth keeping: fields were populated only where the entry's own body already states the fact, so this restates what the catalog knows and no verified: date moved. A first attempt used regex over the bodies and was discarded: it read "0x72" in an author's name as a grid size and the word "platformer" in unrelated prose as a side-scroller. The bodies were read instead.
• Deferred, and now visible rather than hidden:
  • top_down returns exactly one entry (dcss-tiles, which is needs-review). That is the coverage gap the task test found in the first pass, now legible in the UI. It is a sourcing problem, not a tagging one.
  • Three tile packs are deliberately untagged: kenney-1-bit-pack and kenney-tiny-dungeon read as top-down roguelike tiles, and ox72-dungeon-tileset is the sibling of an entry already classified isometric_3_4, but none of the three states its perspective in its own body. Confirming them means looking at the packs, which is a sourcing task for a future run. Do not infer them.
  • The rest of 2d beyond these, and every other category, still has no camera_perspective. That is correct for tools, fonts and audio; it is an open question for characters and parts of 3d, where the field is arguably not applicable at all. Decide the scope before populating further.
• Next highest-value action: source a CC0 4-directional top-down character set and a top-down tileset with a stated perspective: tilesets done in the fourth pass above; the character half remains open.

2026-09-22 (second pass, same session)

Picked up the two items the first pass deferred. Batches F and E.

• Executed:
  • F, GPL version precision. Read each of the 15 bare-GPL projects' own licensing statements at source. 8 had an explicit election and were corrected: cloudcompare, lmms and tiled to GPL-2.0-or-later; goxel, gimp, espeak-ng and sollumz to GPL-3.0-or-later; and inkscape from GPL-2.0 to GPL-3.0-or-later, which is a correction rather than precision, because its own COPYING says the complete binaries are GPLv3-or-later while its licensing page still shows the GPLv2 title. license_spdx coverage 219 -> 227 (77.2%). verified moved to 2026-09-22 on these 8 only, each with a dated Evidence line quoting what was read.
  • Added check V11: a category README row may not contradict its entry's frontmatter. It found two real drifts (tiled's row said GPL-3.0 against frontmatter GPL-2.0; jsfxr's still said public-domain after batch B corrected it to Unlicense).
  • E, documentation and decision support. docs/fonts.md and docs/geodata.md, both registered in site/config.json and linked from catalog/README.md. Comparison tables for the icon cluster in catalog/2d/README.md and the tool near-duplicates in catalog/tools/README.md.
• Deferred, still open:
  • 7 entries keep a bare GPL value on purpose and now say why in their notes. krita and meshlab have per-file GPL-2.0-or-later headers but ship the GPLv3 text, so the distribution is GPLv3 with no single election. audacity says "GPLv3" while most files are GPLv2-or-later and VST3 code constrains the combination. blockbench, libresprite and materialize ship stock licence text with no election. tenacity could not be read at all: Codeberg returned 403 to automated requests, so its value is unchanged and unconfirmed, and it is the one worth a manual look.
  • Eight of the ten decision-support clusters still have no comparison line: the four colourblindness tools are described in prose but the remaining clusters (Godot scatter, dungeon tilesets, and the rest) are untouched.
  • Everything in the first-pass list below that is not struck through here.
• Parked, do not re-litigate:
  • A stock GPL licence file proves nothing about the project's election. Its own "How to Apply These Terms" appendix contains the words "any later version". A pass in this session nearly recorded eight wrong answers by pattern-matching that phrase in 35KB LICENSE files. Only a project-authored statement counts: a source-file header, a README sentence, or a short project-written licence note.
  • krita and meshlab are not defects. Their bare GPL-3.0 is the honest value. Checked 2026-09-22 against two sources each.
  • Annotated cells in category README tables are deliberate. CC0*, CC-BY?, varies (SA) and varies (CC0/MIT/GPL) carry footnote warnings the plain value cannot. V11 strips a trailing marker or parenthetical before comparing; do not "normalise" these away. An earlier attempt in this session stripped 10 of them and was reverted.
  • V11 only inspects rows whose first cell is the entry link. Category READMEs may also hold comparison tables that link entries from prose cells; those are not listings. Matching any row produced 22 false positives.
• Next highest-value action: unchanged from the first pass below. Populate camera_perspective and grid_dimensions.

2026-09-22

• Measured: 294 entries (263 active, 29 needs-review, 2 deprecated); 262 commercial true, 23 unknown, 8 varies, 1 false; 20 distinct license values; license_spdx 209/294, publisher 128/294. Stale share 0 percent: every verified date is under 90 days old because the repo is 65 days old. Required fields 294/294, zero misses. Link sweep of all 294 urls: 282 returned 2xx, 12 returned 403/454 bot blocks, and zero were dead.
• Integrity check that mattered most: of the 292 entries with a dated ## Evidence section, zero had a verified date newer than their newest evidence date. No date in this catalog has been carried forward without evidence behind it.
• Executed: batches A, B, C, D, one commit each, validator and build green after each.
  • A: spdx-allowed.json +7 identifiers; license_spdx backfilled on 10 entries (209 -> 219); publisher rule in CONTRIBUTING clarified.
  • B: 10 new checks in site/checks.mjs behind site/license-vocabulary.json, with site/checks.test.mjs (28 assertions) wired into both workflows; 6 entries edited so the checks could ship.
  • C: 3 url fields repointed after publisher domain moves.
  • D: prerendering, the deprecated-filter fix, verified age in the UI, permalinks, URL state, sort, clipboard, legend, dark scheme, sitemap/robots/404.
• Deferred:
  • Batch E (docs and decision support): done in the second pass above.
  • 15 entries carrying license: GPL-2.0 or GPL-3.0: 8 resolved in the second pass above; 7 remain bare on purpose, with reasons recorded in their notes.
  • 12 urls returned 403 or 454 (fab, smithsonian, scan-the-world, sonniss, pixabay-audio, zapsplat, musopen, inkscape, tenacity, cloudcompare, vroid-studio, godot-shaders). Bot blocks, inconclusive, not defects. No verified was moved. They need a browser-based check whenever one of them next needs re-verifying.
  • og:image is omitted rather than faked. It needs a real image file and the binary-asset rule keeps one out of the repo; decide where it should live.
  • site/dist/data.json is deployed but unused by the page. It may be a deliberate JSON endpoint. If it is, say so in site/README.md; if not, drop it.
• Parked, do not re-litigate:
  • One entry equals one pack. Kenney 44, Quaternius 23 and KayKit 13 entries look like redundancy and are not; provenance.md settles it. Three publishers holding 27 percent of the catalog is a consequence of that rule, not a defect.
  • Aggregators with commercial: varies appear under the Commercial OK filter, labeled per-file review. CONTRIBUTING states this is deliberate so they are neither silently excluded nor silently treated as a blanket grant.
  • publisher on a single-entry publisher is allowed. This run first read the CONTRIBUTING rule as a gate and proposed deleting the field from Tiny Speck, Screaming Brain Studios and Sparklin. That was the wrong reading: the rule's real prohibition is generic hosts, and deleting accurate rights-holder data to satisfy a formatting rule loses information. The wording was clarified instead.
  • blender.md carries no publisher while the Blender Studio asset bundles do. Not an inconsistency. The Blender Foundation ships the application; Blender Studio holds the asset rights. Check V7 is written to allow exactly this.
  • OFL font entries set attribution_required: false. Correct. OFL obliges a notice carried with the font files, not a credits-screen line. The vocabulary records this as attribution class notice so V4 does not fire on them.
  • No virtualization, pagination or search debounce. Measured at 294 entries and below the threshold where they pay for themselves. Measure again before proposing.
• Next highest-value action: populate camera_perspective and grid_dimensions (done in the third pass above). The task-based coverage test failed hardest not on missing sources but on missing taxonomy: a developer cannot filter for a top-down 2D source, because camera_perspective is set on 11 of 294 entries and grid_dimensions on 6, and the site does not expose either. The schema already solved this problem and nothing filled it in. After that, the three concrete source gaps the task test found: rigged first-person arms, CC0 4-directional top-down character sprites, and rubble/pre-fractured debris geometry.